But for the federal hatecrimes bill, its not a bug, its a feature. What appears to be happening is the federal government supervising the state government, and if the verdict is not satisfactory, bringing more charges. People usually think of hatecrimes bills as sentenceenhancers and indeed, many state hate. George zimmerman reutersjoe burbank george zimmerman. To demand that zimmerman again be brought before a court to face further legal action for the same offense crosses the line from serving justice to serving unconscionable vengeance. Thomas iii advances an integrated theory of double jeopardy law, a theory anchored in historical, doctrinal, and philosophical method. Reacting to zimmerman verdict, reuters news, july 15, 20. Trayvon martin whom obama said could have been my son was no innocent, having a background as a truant, a liar, a thief, a schoolyard bully, and a doper. George zimmerman juror shelves book plans after angry backlash. There was no evidence proving this was a hate crime, the only possible charge against zimmerman. Why hate crime laws are all wrong slade mendenhall july 17, 20 editorials after over a year of investigation, trial, sensationalism, outright lies by media outlets, and a trial that seemed vulnerable to going either way, the case of george zimmerman and trayvon martin has entered a. George zimmerman, right, shot trayvon martin to death during a confrontation in a florida gated community in 2012. Itll generate some juicy debates over whether the new federal hate crimes statute is constitutional and whether double jeopardy really does allow the feds to bring charges after a defendants been acquitted of a state charge. Video in a new column i address the constitutional issues, under double jeopardy, of the federal government potentially trying george zimmerman for a civil rights violation hate crimes statute.
Top 10 commentaries on the george zimmerman not guilty verdict. Hate crime laws and double jeopardy posted in race, the death penalty by chamblee54 on june 5, 2012 the first mistake was reading more about george zimmerman. Wont file charges in trayvon martin killing the new. Aug 27, 2015 trayvon martin killer george zimmerman proves hes a racist homophobe the man who killed an unarmed black teen in florida is spouting off about the murder of two virginia journalists, blaming. Today, the george zimmerman case will probably go to a florida jury. The orlando sentinel newspaper today reported that the department of justice has assembled a federal grand jury to meet next week to hear testimony about whether george zimmerman violated trayvon martins civil rights on the night that zimmerman ultimately killed martin in selfdefense. Holder may undermine rule of law with challenge to zimmerman. The meaning of the zimmerman trial the freedom pub. There is no double jeopardy here, but the prosecutors in florida, who. Double jeopardy and the zimmerman trial can he be tried all over again.
The aclu actually stated that they believe double jeopardy would be involved and suggested that doj not get involved. If the constitution protects against double jeopardy. Zimmerman was acquitted saturday night in the fatal 2012 shooting. Jul 23, 20 video in a new column i address the constitutional issues, under double jeopardy, of the federal government potentially trying george zimmerman for a civil rights violation hate crimes statute. Federal criminal charges under the james byrd hate crime bill. Double jeopardy, in law, protection against the use by the state of certain multiple forms of prosecution. His victim didnt just happen to be black, and dedmon wasnt convicted of a hate crime based on flimsy circumstantial evidence that this one time he posted a nasty comment online about minorities. Trayvon martin killer george zimmerman proves hes a racist. How hate crimes law threatens all of us john caile no sooner had george zimmerman been acquitted of murder in the case of trayvon martin than attorney general eric holder announced that the justice department would continue its ongoing investigation into the matter. Trayvon martin killer george zimmerman proves hes a racist homophobe the man who killed an unarmed black teen in florida is spouting off about. For the government to win a case against zimmerman on civil rights charges. Some politicians are demanding a second prosecution of zimmerman, this time for. Theres a silver lining to the doj bringing federal charges if youre a conlaw junkie, though. The justice department resumes its investigation of the shooting of trayvon martin to consider hate crime charges against george zimmerman.
Apr 27, 2009 the possibility of double jeopardy always exists when congress passes a broadlyworded criminal statute, under the dual sovereignty loophole. We now have a position on the books in the state of florida where an unarmed. If you know anything about the law, zimmerman cant be tried for the same crime. July 19, 20 what would real justice for trayvon martin look like. Hate crimes and double jeopardy the washington post. Jul 19, 20 web only features july 19, 20 what would real justice for trayvon martin look like. Obama administration considering fed prosecution if zimmerman. Punishment without crime isidore zimmerman, francis bond, drew pearson on. Jul 15, 20 the justice department shouldnt file civil rights charges against george zimmerman, as millions of americans would view such a case as double jeopardy, according to a wall street journal editorial. Us could bring hate crime charge against george zimmerman. Some time later, they confessed to the murder to a journalist once assured that double jeopardy meant they could not be tried again. Supreme court of the united states reason foundation.
Federal prosecutions for civil rights violations and hate crimes. If the justice department prosecutes george zimmerman for violating a federal hate crime law, his right against double jeopardy will be violated. The only other seeming possibility would be the socalled federal hate crimes provision. But the supreme court has long since held that, under the independent sovereigns doctrine, accused criminals are not subject to double jeopardy when they are tried under separate laws created by. Doublejeopardy protections, the dualsovereignty rule, and the. Et on sunday 714 cnn leaders at the nations oldest civil rights organization have spoken with senior members of u. Thomas iii advances an integrated theory of double jeopardy law, a theory anchored in historical, doctrinal, and. George zimmerman hate crime prosecution will not happen youtube. A polite way to say that we cant find anything to charge zimmerman with. Jul 15, 20 trayvon martin is dead, george zimmerman has been acquitted, and millions of people are outraged. Posts about double jeopardy written by jack marshall. Does federal hate crime prosecution constitute double jeopardy. Aug 27, 2015 george zimmerman reutersjoe burbank george zimmerman.
The department of justice wants to waste more money trying him for a federal hate crime. He was convicted of a hate crime because it demonstrably was a hate crime. George zimmerman was originally processed without any racial influence and lawfully released according to the evidence of the incident. This is not the rodney king case, where the feds could bring separate charges against public officials for government violations of civil rights. The aftermath of the george zimmerman trial has brought an expected. Doj seeks double jeopardy for zimmerman ellington, ct. Trying him under the hate crimes act would very clearly be double jeopardy. Then the racist groups caught wind of it and decided to use it to stir up their continuing racial strife and woe is me propaganda. Obama calls for calm in wake of george zimmerman verdict. In the first book length book on the subject in over a quarter century, george c.
These options are supposed to remedy the failure of the florida jury to dispense the correct. This is not the rodney king case, where the feds could bring separate charges against public officials for. The justice department has few options in the investigation of the death of florida teen trayvon martin. Civil rights charges against zimmerman double jeopardy. Double jeopardy and the federal hate crimes bill overlawyered. Jul 07, 20 trying him under the hate crimes act would very clearly be double jeopardy. Even though, as i point out in my book the transformation of the. After escaping the electric chair by two hours, he entered. The prosecution was limited by shoddy police work in the crucial. People usually think of hatecrimes bills as sentenceenhancers and indeed, many state hatecrime laws take that format. He could also be indicted for a federal hate crime. Despite video footage, a state criminal trial ended in acquittals for those charged. In general, in countries observing the rule of double jeopardy, a person cannot be tried twice for the same crime based on the same conduct. Pg thought this was a bit weird, and did some research.
H steerforth press, 20 citing a recent book where the author. But the two classic arguments against hate crime legislation still apply to the shepard bill, which expands the number of protected classes to. Naacp talking to justice department about zimmerman case. Beyond that, hatecrime laws and prohibitions on housing discrimination might be. Legal issue, trolling, hate speech, offensivethreatening language, copyright, spam, other. Beyond that, hate crime laws and prohibitions on housing discrimination might be.
Obama administration considering fed prosecution if. Zimmerman federal hate crimes prosecution would be double. Although federal prosecutors ultimately decided not to file charges against zimmerman, they have the. Fbi may charge george zimmerman with hate crime, could face death penalty. The hate crimes law president barack obama championed and signed in 2009 makes it easier to pursue a federal criminal case against george zimmerman over the death of trayvon martin. The possibility of double jeopardy always exists when congress passes a broadlyworded criminal statute, under the dual sovereignty loophole. The idea is that if you are acquited of a crime, you should not be tried again for the same offense. Virginia hate crime shootings committed by pansy and condoned by ignorant baboon barack obama the deaths of alison parker and adam.
George zimmerman hate crime prosecution will not happen. Jul 15, 20 the justice department resumes its investigation of the shooting of trayvon martin to consider hate crime charges against george zimmerman on the bonus show. Mar 30, 2012 george zimmerman was originally processed without any racial influence and lawfully released according to the evidence of the incident. Jun 05, 2012 does federal hate crime prosecution constitute double jeopardy. The justice department shouldnt file civil rights charges against george zimmerman, as millions of americans would view such a case as double jeopardy, according to a wall street journal editorial. Wouldnt double jeopardy stop zimmerman from being charged all over again. George zimmermans acquittal in the shooting death of black teenager. Mar 21, 2012 was trayvon martins killing a federal hate crime. George zimmerman, the gunobsessed killer of unarmed teen trayvon martin, offered some racist comments on the fatal shootings of two tv journalists by a disgruntled former colleague. Isidore zimmerman spent 24 years and 10 months in prison for a crime he did not commit. Attorney general eric holders team at the justice department about pursuing federal civil rights charges against george zimmerman, naacp president ben jealous said sunday, though holder himself has noted the high bar for establishing a hate crime.
For more information on when a person can be placed in double jeopardy. Double jeopardy protections, the dualsovereignty rule, and the. Trayvon martin is dead, george zimmerman has been acquitted, and millions of people are outraged. The aclu believes the double jeopardy clause of the constitution. But, even if he is acquitted, george zimmerman may face federal charges. In prosecuting the police officers a second time, the federal government is. Public opinion in some surrealistic form of double jeopardy by the launching of a federal investigation funded by our tax. First, there is the question for all practical purposes of double jeopardy. The statute is inane because it defies the ageold definition of crime. Federal hate crime laws were written specifically to make the constitutional prohibition on double jeopardy a dead letter if the federal government wants to prosecute someone for political reasons read. The meaning of the zimmerman trial the american spectator. Double jeopardy and the zimmerman trial can he be tried. When state prosecutors fail to pursue charges for a hate crime, federal prosecutors.
Aug 07, 2009 welcome to a new age of double jeopardy. Obama restarts hate crime investigation of zimmerman. Double jeopardy and the zimmerman trial can he be tried all. Bringing federal charges against a private individual like zimmerman would require showing that zimmerman committed an intentional hate crime targeting martin for attack. And the penalty for committing a robbery that is also a hate crime is more severe. What appears to be happening is the federal government supervising the state government, and if. But the two classic arguments against hatecrime legislation still apply to the shepard bill, which expands the number of protected classes to. Because in americawhile we think you cant be charged for the same crime twicethere really is double jeopardy, in the form of federal charges. Mitch albom writes new book to raise money for covid19 relief. Jul 17, 20 why hate crime laws are all wrong slade mendenhall july 17, 20 editorials after over a year of investigation, trial, sensationalism, outright lies by media outlets, and a trial that seemed vulnerable to going either way, the case of george zimmerman and trayvon martin has entered a new phase. What would real justice for trayvon martin look like.
932 412 599 513 1460 194 1343 379 688 185 1447 83 183 1091 658 1025 141 1092 674 1051 615 1470 1311 150 1154 125 726 763 1358 314 548 30 344